Subscribe to my Free Newsletter 
Email:

Read Issue 4 of The Critical Friend

Read Issue 1, Issue 2, Issue 3, Issue 4 or Issue 5 of The Critical Friend

Index

Enter your email address above to be added to the newsletter mailing list!
The Critical Friend Views & news on learning
Volume 5 - April 2009

From the minute a child is taught to play a musical instrument, he's no longer poor. He becomes a child in-progress heading for a professional level, who will later become a full citizen.

- José Antonio Abreu (2009) accepting the TED Prize for his brilliant work in creating the Venezuelan Youth Orchestra system benefitting hundreds of thousands of the poorest children across his nation,

In this issue
  • Wow!
  • Amazing Summer Learning for Creative Educators!
  • Constructivist Celebration Comes to Seattle - May 16th!
  • On Newstands Near You
  • "New" Whitepaper
  • "Ancient" Papert Paper Unearthed
  • My Blog is Under Renovation
  • To Qatar and Back
  • New Education Essays by Dr. Marvin Minsky
  • The Best Books for Creative Educators
  • Fantastic New Book About Learning!
  • What Makes a Good Project?
  • Where I'll Be
  • The Latest Book Fad & Review
  • Random Interesting Stuff
  • About the Critical Friend...

  • Amazing Summer Learning for Creative Educators!

    Join Macarthur Genius Deborah Meier; legendary educator and author of 40 books Herbert Kohl; digital imaging and photography expert Lesa Snider King; author/animator/illustrator Peter Reynolds; Dr. Gary Stager and a stellar faculty at the Constructing Modern Knowledge.

    Constructing Modern Knowledge provides a rich learning environment in which educators have the time, resources and inspiration to learn via the creation of personally meaningful technology projects while interacting with some of the wisest educators of our time.

    Social events include an institute dinner and reception at the legendary FableVision Studios before a big night out in Boston. A preconference science and history tour of Boston is available for a nominal fee on July 12th.

    Constructing Modern Knowledge respects the budgets of schools and educators by keeping registration costs affordable and by offering team discounts. The institute is appropriate for all K-12 educators, administrators and teacher educators.

    Learn more about Constructing Modern Knowledge, the professional learning event of the year at constructingmodernknowledge.com

    Early-bird registration ends May 1st. CEUs are also available.


    Constructivist Celebration Comes to Seattle - May 16th!

    The first ever NCCE Constructivist Celebration is an opportunity for you to let your creativity run free with the world's best open-ended software tools in a great setting with enthusiastic colleagues who share your commitment to children, computing, creativity and constructivism. You might think of this stimulating event as a spa day for your mind and soul!

    The day will be kicked off with an inspirational keynote, "Creativity, Community and Computing," followed by five hours of creativity on your own laptop using software provided by consortium members.

    The Constructivist Celebration is an incredibly affordable event for you and your colleagues. $55 gets you free software from Inspiration, FableVision, Tech4learning and LCSI, a great lunch and the day's activities.

    The Constructivist Celebration is a partnership between the Constructivist Consortium, NCCE and the Washington State Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction.

    This workshop and the hands-on activities are appropriate for PK-12 teachers, technology coordinators and teacher educators. Members of the Constructivist Consortium (including Melinda Kolk, Dennis Harper and Gary Stager) will lead creative activities and serve as guides throughout the day.


    On Newstands Near You
    Gary holds his magazine at NY newstandLast June, a fine young magazine called GOOD contacted me. They said that they appreciated my writing and would like to work with me. Little did I know that they meant work then!

    I was about to leave for NECC, lead the Constructivist Celebration, plan Constructing Modern Knowledge and take my son on a 4-day tour of historical civil rights sites in Montgomery, Birmingham, Selma, Memphis and Little Rock. I stayed in my hotel room at NECC writing and ended up dealing with fact-checkers via iPhone from the parsonage where the King family lived in Montgomery. However, the resulting article was well worth the effort and sacrifice. The GOOD team was incredibly professional and the art direction the article received was insane (in a good way).

    Then, they made my article the cover story of the September/October 2008 issue. It was amazing to have a a major feature article published in a magazine that my parents could actually buy! If you have not yet encountered GOOD, I recommend it. They give 100% of their subscription money to charity too.

    I also continue to write for the Huffington Post. I hope to make a small impact on the state of educational reporting and introduce critical education issues to the Huffington Post's impressive readership.

    You may subscribe to my Huffington Post articles and read new my recent work, including some harsh critiques of President Obama's disappointing education policies here.


    "New" Whitepaper

    Back in 1996, I presented a couple of public lectures in Melbourne, Australia. Portions of those seminars were published in a monograph entitled, Computing and the Internet in Schools: An International Perspective on Developments and Directions.

    It seems to me that after fifteen years of 'Computer Literacy' nobody seems to be really 'literate', and very few can 'compute'. Since I am among friends, dare I whisper the awful secret that we have not really achieved very much?
    I no longer have a digital copy of that document and spent years trying to figure out a good way to get it online since it was printed in blue ink (making it difficult to scan) and even if I did scan it, the OCR would be terrible. After wasting time and money buying a series of crappy sheet-fed scanners, I finally bit the bullet and bought a Fujitsu ScanSnap S510M Instant PDF Sheet-Fed Scanner (Mac model) (PC)

    This scanner rocks! It's reliable, fast at more than 30 pages per minute BOTH SIDES and automatically knows if one side is blank or if the document is upside down or sideways. It's the best investment I've made in ages. The OCR even works! Now, I'm able to archive all sorts of gems from the past. I'll share some via my blogs in the future.

    In any event, I cut up a copy of the monograph, inserted it into the new scanner and now I can share it with the world in a searchable PDF format.
    Remember that co-operation begins at home. If you have classrooms in rows, where the children never talk to each other, then it is highly unlikely that you are going to succeed with any collaborative projects in cyberspace.
    Was I prescient in the predictions made about the future more than twelve years ago - long before anyone was blogging or talking about 2.0 anything?
    To my mind, the notion that we are going to use the greatest communication vehicle ever, to deliver lesson plans, is not a useful one. In a worst case scenario, if implemented, such an approach could be a way of controlling what teachers do and what children learn.
    (NCLB anyone? BrainPop? 'Interactive Whiteboards' with content delivered by the vendor?)

    Read it and you decide. I'd love to hear what you think!

    (quotes from 1996 document by Gary S. Stager, Ph.D.)


    "Ancient" Papert Paper Unearthed

    In 1970, my friend, colleague and mentor Dr. Seymour Papert wrote a seminal paper on children, computers and learning. The groundbreaking work, Teaching Children Thinking, was published in 1971. Until recently, I had not read this lost gem. With a bit of help from Cynthia Solomon, Marvin Minsky and the Interwebs machine I am able to share this important article with you.

    "The phrase, "technology and education" usually means inventing new gadgets to teach the same old stuff in a thinly disguised version of the same old way. Moreover, if the gadgets are computers, the same old teaching becomes incredibly more expensive and biased towards its dumbest parts, namely the kind of rote learning in which measurable results can be obtained by treating the children like pigeons in a skinner box." (Papert 1971)

    By the way, Dr. Nicholas Negroponte talks of the importance of this early Papert paper in this recently published TED Talk.

    History buffs should also watch Negroponte's TED Talk from 1984 to see how well his predictions for the future fared. That's the year the Macintosh was released.


    My Blog is Under Renovation

    I haven't been contributing much to my personal blog lately. "Stager-to-Go" got hosed by Blogger and Google refuses to fix the documented bug. This makes it impossible for me to host and upload to my Blogger site. I guess you get what you pay for.

    So, I have been relocating and rebuilding my blog in my spare time (and as time permits). For those who just can't live without their regular dose of Stager, point your browser to my new WordPress blog at http://stager.tv/blog. Once there, you may subscribe to the blog as well.

    However, remember that the new blog is IN BETA and not all of the clever features work yet. So, please be kind. All of the content is fine. Some of the menus and such may not yet be operational.

    Over time I also hope that the new blog will include articles I wrote for the now (regrettably) deceased site, The Pulse: Education's Place for Debate, but that content is in an even bigger heap of busted HTML.


    To Qatar and Back

    In 1990 I led professional development in the world's first two "laptop schools." Back then I got to work in schools for weeks and months at a time. My brief was to do anything I thought would improve the quality of the institution. It's been a while since I've had the chance to do such a variety of work in one school.

    Last November, I had the privilege of spending a week working at the Qatar Academy in Doha's Education City. I was invited by Flat Classroom pioneer and edublogger extraordinaire, Julie Lindsay, to help her school prepare for going "1:1" next September. My work began a fews hour after my long flight to the Middle East and didn't end until a few hours before I left.

    I taught distinct computer-rich demo lessons in a English, math and science classes. I taught two long classes of elementary school students in which they used data analysis to solve an open-ended problem and another in which they programmed their own video games. The classes used the Web, collaborative tools, InspireData, MicroWorlds EX and StarLogo TNG. My goal was to create a sufficient number of different models of computer use to give the faculty possibilities to consider after I left.

    I also participated in discussions with each department of the school, including P.E. and preschool, plus met with senior administrators and members of ICTQatar. I gave a public keynote and a presentation for primary school parents attended by an adorable class of incredibly well-behaved first graders. In my "spare time" I led two hands-on teacher workshops and met with Julie's 21st Century Learning Group. My meeting with the school's student tech team was equally rewarding.

    The week was exhausting, but exhilerating. I met some fabulous educators and enjoyed their hospitality. Best of all, I was thrilled to have the opportunity to flex all of my muscles. I loved working for one school where I could discuss Reggio Emilia, visual art, emergent behavior, computer science, music composition, network policies, school reform and so much more. The Qatar Academy was receptive and embraced learning with both hands. I had the time of my life!

    Julie Lindsay wrote a quite generous blog post reflecting on my work in her school. It's worth a read.

    If you don't quite believe that I was worked like a rented camel, take a look at my schedule!

    In March, I was invited back to Qatar to speak at a conference on the future of education and ICT in the relatively new nation.


    New Education Essays by Dr. Marvin Minsky

    Dr. Marvin Minsky, one of the world's most important scientists, great thinkers and master tinkerers, has begun writing a series of provocative essays about education for the One Laptop Per Child community on their wiki. This growing collection of essays make for great reading and may spark debate with your colleagues.

    To date, the collection of essays includes:

    1. What Makes Mathematics Hard to Learn?
    2. Effects Of Grade-Based Segregation
    3. Role Models, Mentors, and Imprimers and Thinking
    4. Questioning "General" Education
    5. Education and Psychology

    It has been one of the great pleasures of my life to have spent time with Dr. Minsky. I was honored that he agreed to participate in Constructing Modern Knowledge last summer. I hope these essays inspire thought and even better, action.

    If you have not read Minsky's remarkable books, The Society of Mind or The Emotion Machine: Commonsense Thinking, Artificial Intelligence, and the Future of the Human Mind, what are you waiting for? (Both books are available for a song via these links to Amazon.com)


    The Best Books for Creative Educators

    As a service to creative educators, The Constructivist Consortium has created an online bookstore for educators looking for the best books about learning and coolest items to use in the classroom.

    The Constructivist Consortium is a sponsor of Contructing Modern Knowledge this July.


    Fantastic New Book About Learning!

    Harvard Professor and Project Zero co-founder, David Perkins, has just published a stunning book about learning and teaching. Making Learning Whole: How Seven Principles of Teaching Can Transform Education makes a compelling, sophisticated and cogent case for learner-centered teaching in language any parent would understand. Highly recommended!


    What Makes a Good Project?

    Educators advocating project-based learning could use some help articulating the rationale for such an approach. My new article, What Makes a Good Project?, describes the eight elements that make a project worthwhile.

    Part II of the article, Raising Our Standards - Developing Projects that Endure, from The Creative Educator Magazine, explores evaluation issues related to effective project-based learning. Both articles may be downloaded as PDF files here.


    Where I'll Be

    Dr. Stager's upcoming schedule includes the following speaking, teaching and consulting engagements:

    • April 23 - Montreal, Canada Keynote speaker at day-long seminar, The Best Education Ideas in the World, for Quebec's Inspector Generals.
    • April 30 - Boca Raton, FL Keynote speaker at National Center for Education Research and Technology Conference (superintendents)
    • May 14-15 - Brooklyn, NY Robotics and MicroWorlds workshop leader for middle school student tech leaders
    • May 16 - Renton, WA Keynote speaker at the Constructivist Celebration co-sponsored by NCCE and OSPI
    • June 28 - Washington, D.C. Keynote speaker at the Constructivist Consortium's third annual Constructivist Celebration at NECC
    • June 28 - July 1 Washington D.C. Featured Presenter at the National Educational Computing Conference
    • July 6-10 - Brooklyn, NY Leader of science and technology summer camp program for middle student tech leaders
    • July 8 - Princeton, NJ Keynote speaker at The Principal's Center for Educational Leadership
    • July 12-16 Manchester, NH Host/organizer of Constructing Modern Knowledge
    • July 27-31 Bento Gonçalves, Brasil Presenting three new papers at the World Conference on Computers in Education
    • August 17-20 Los Angeles, CA Leading team of of experts in 1:1 computing professional development for independent middle school
    • Late August - Australia Plan to speak and consult across Australia Contact Gary to schedule PD services.
    • October 6-9 Christchurch, New Zealand Keynote speaker at the Ulearn09 Conference
    • Early October - New Zealand Opportunities for professional development and consulting. Contact Gary to schedule PD services.

    Learn how your school, company, organization may work with Dr. Stager by downloading this brochure or by clicking here.


    The Latest Book Fad & Review

    Disrupting Class: How Disruptive Innovation Will Change the Way the World Learns by Clayton Christensen is the latest book craze catching the attention of school administrators and conference speakers.

    Dr. Andrew Zucker of the Concord Consortium has written a very strong review of the book. It's worth a read!


    Random Interesting Stuff

    Follow me on Twitter

    Marketing and evangelism guru, Guy Kawasaki, has published his best book since the classic, Selling the Dream. You might think of his new book, Reality Check: The Irreverent Guide to Outsmarting, Outmanaging, and Outmarketing Your Competition, as a manual for your life. Kawasaki's book is full of practical advice for navigating the information age world and despite its title is not a get-rich-quick tome. I've given copies to colleagues, grad students and even a high school senior. Highly recommended!

    Read savage reviews of Tom Friedman's journalism. Vanity Fair recently published an article entitled, Tom Friedman's Five Worst Predictions.

    John Taylor Gatto's new book, Weapons of Mass Instruction A Schoolteacher's Journey through the Dark World of Compulsory Schooling, is a great read and at times like being beaten over the head with an interactive whiteboard.

    The best jazz CD in years

    A high-def DVD of Stevie Wonder's brilliant 2008 tour (I saw it at the Hollywood Bowl)

    Check out the pile of books and assorted stuff sitting next to my virtual bed.

    A really cool First Amdendment web site for educators and students.

    Jo Boaler's new book, What's Math Got to Do with It?: Helping Children Learn to Love Their Least Favorite Subject--and Why It's Important for America is terrific. Her provocative article, Where has All the Knowledge Gone?, does an extremely good job of explaining how politics has caused "research" to be manipulated on behalf of certain pedagogical theories at the expense of student learning. Read the article quickly before EdWeek starts charging for it!

    Books by Constructing Modern Knowledge guest speaker, Herbert Kohl

    Books by Constructing Modern Knowledge guest speaker, Deborah Meier

    Constructing Modern Knowledge Guest Speaker, Lesa Snider King, is the author of PhotoShop CS4; The Missing Manual.

    The best videogame for under $15 Big fun for the whole family!


    Professional-quality recording microphone for your iPod

    eyeball mic

    Small USB webcam (Mac/PC) with terrific audio

    Great online collection of videos on learning and technology


    Books and resources for creative educators


    If you like the USB Snowball Microphone, you'll love the smaller, portable, less expensive Snowflake Mic!

    You really need to be familiar with the extraordinary "El Sistema" program using classical music to improve the lives and communities of hundreds of thousands of poor children across Venezuela. Watch the El Sistema founder, José Abreu collect the $100,000 TED Prize and the performance by the magnificent The Teresa Carreño Youth Orchestra. conducted by former "El Sistema" student, Gustavo Dudamel (newly appointed conductor of the Los Angeles Philharmonic).

    Anyone interested in 1:1 computing in education should take note of the resources provided by the Anytime Anywhere Learning Foundation

    Charlie Bartlett is a charming and chilling movie about high school angst with Robert Downey Jr.'s stellar performance.

    I've been moving all of my web and blog hosting to 1and1.com with great success and I'm saving money too! Check them out! Their tools are great, prices affordable and it was easy to host my own Wordpress sites.


    About the Critical Friend...

    The Critical Friend is an online newsletter for 21st Century educators published free-of-charge by Gary Stager.

    It offers unique perspectives on important educational issues, debunks hype and confronts special interests all with a sense of humor. This newsletter analyzes trends and challenges the status quo.

    Thoughtful educators, parents and decision-makers may be inspired to rethink their educational beliefs and practices. The Critical Friend will blow the whistle on superficial education journalism and attempts to put the latest "crisis du jour" into perspective.

    Pass this newsletter along to friends and unsubscribe if you wish not to be bothered in the future.


    Wow!

    It's been about six months since I began writing this issue of The Critical Friend. There always seems to be more exciting news, stories and resources to share with you.

    Since our last issue, life has been rich and hectic. Last August, I accepted a full-time position at Pepperdine University. After fifteen years at Pepperdine, I am now Visiting Professor and teaching a variety of courses at the Masters and doctoral level. I just returned from accompanying doctoral students on a tour of the MIT Media Lab, MIT Design Lab, Henry Jenkins' New Media Literacies Group and FableVision Studios.


    Last June, a record 140 educators filled Casa Rio Restaurant on the San Antonio Riverwalk for the Constructivist Celebration. Enjoying the time to collaborate, share, create, laugh and learn in addition to a lavish lunch of Mexican food nourished each participant. I kicked off the day and Pete Reynolds brought it to a close in the best talk I've seen him give in the twenty years we've worked together.

    In July I hosted the first ever Constructing Modern Knowledge summer institute.

    Pete Reynolds pitches in at CMK08
    Educators from as far away as Sudan and Israel spent four action-packed days exploring the rich and wondrous ways computers may enhance learning. Their ample project development time was interrupted occasionally by interactions with Alfie Kohn, Bob Tinker, Peter Reynolds and support from my magnificent faculty, including Cynthia Solomon, Sylvia Martinez, John Stetson and Melinda Kolk. What a treat it was when one of the world's greatest scientists, thinkers and raconteurs, Dr. Marvin Minsky spent 90 minutes chatting with us on an extraordinary range of subjects.

    Alfie Kohn at CMK08

    Experimenting with XOs at CMK08

    Bob Tinker  looks at Karen Janoski's
molecular model
    Since the summer of 2008 I have been involved in leading a funded project with Generation YES to improve middle school science education via robotics, MicroWorlds programming and peer mentoring in Brooklyn, NY schools. It has been great fun and continues to evolve.

    In late September I returned to my "second home," Australia, after too long an absence. While there, I spoke at the Australian Conference on Educational Computing in Canberra. It was great catching-up with old friends and colleagues. Best of all, I have been invited to keynote the April 2010 ACEC in a city that I love, Melbourne. One of the first keynotes I ever did was the 1992 ACEC conference in Melbourne. 2010 marks the twentieth anniversary of my work in Australia - a very special occasion.

    My article, "School Wars," was the cover story in a fantastic young publication, GOOD Magazine. The art direction for the article is amazing, the editorial process was rewarding and my parents could actually go to a store and buy something I wrote. Right-wing Washington D.C. think tanks absolutely hated the article - a sign that I did my job. I also continue to write for The Huffington Post and am looking for other editorial opportunities.


    In November I spent a whirlwind week working at the Qatar Academy, the PK-12 school within Qatar's enormous Education City complex in Doha. I worked from sunrise to sundown and had a blast. From the Middle Eastern desert of Qatar, I flew to Rochester to be the closing keynote again at NYSCATE's annual conference (for my money the best edtech conference in America). Other keynote speakers were my pal David Jakes, Don Knzezek and Marc Prensky.


    After attending the Inauguration of President Obama and an inaugural ball, I had the great fortune of speaking at Educon 2.1 in Philadelphia where I met amazing people and participated in a panel discussion on school reform that's the stuff of legend. Prior to Educon, I organized a one-day preconference event, Constructing Modern Math/Science Knowledge. We had a great turnout to work with some of my oldest friends and heroes, including Carolyn Staudt, David Thornburg, Ihor Charischak and Brian Silverman. I am so grateful to each of them for their generosity and brilliant contributions to a memorable day.


    In early March it was back to Doha, Qatar to speak at a conference about ICT in Education sponsored by ICTQatar. I've also spoken recently at the National Assocation of Secondary School Principals national conference, the ASCD annual conference and at the NSBA annual conference in San Diego.

    The next few months are action-packed too. There is the first ever Constructivist Celebration in the Pacific Northwest on May 16th. I'm speaking to all of the Director Generals (superintendents) of Quebec and an NCERT superintendent's event. II am also a featured speaker at NECC after leading the Constructivist Celebration at NECC in Washington D.C. on June 28th.

    I will be presenting two new papers at the 2009 World Conference on Computers in Education in Bento Gonçalves, Brazil this July. WCCE 2009 is the fifth consecutive WCCE I've presented papers at since 1990! My team of innovative educators will join me in helping a prestigious Los Angeles school plan for its 1:1 computing launch during an intensive four-day event this August.

    I hope to be in Australia this August after a host of summer work commitments and have been invited to keynote an exciting conference in New Zealand this coming October.

    cmk09badge 
    Best of all, Constructing Modern Knowledge is July 13-16th in Manchester, NH. It's going to be amazing. Please come and if you're not available, spread the word to colleagues. I can't believe the amazing stuff we have planned for this year's institute! More information is found within this newsletter and at constructingmodernknowledge.com.

    Quick Links...

    Previous Issues of The Critical Friend

    What I'm Currently Reading

    Gary's Personal Blog (beta)

    About Gary

    Articles & Papers by Gary

    Reserve Gary for Conferences or PD

    Gary's Upcoming Schedule of Appearances

    The Constructivist Consortium

    Constructing Modern Knowledge - July 13-16, 2009



    Join our mailing list!